Zagat Member Reviews
Frankie & Johnnie's Steakhouse
77 Purchase Street
Rye, NY 10580
Phone: 914-925-3900
Most helpful review submitted by 'ajax1118418'
A very pleasant surprise. Though always packed and very noisy the food was quite good... from meat to fish to veges, everything was prepared as promised and well seasoned. Service was accommodating and not rushed despite the crowd at the door
Reviewed by 'khl721' on March 19, 2011
Been here 4 or 5 times and it is consistently awful. Tasteless steaks, badly prepared. And overpriced to boot. Go to Stew Leonards or Armonk Prime Meats and buy your own steak, cook it on the grill. You'll enjoy it much more, I promise.
Reviewed by 'mikemac1027' on February 6, 2011
Terrific steak, what else would you order at a steakhouse.Very nice setting with a great bar! Typical steakhouse menu, the sides are additional but more than adequate. The wine list is excellent. Avoid being seated on the ground floor, it is cramped and if the bar is lively (it usually is) it is very noisy.
Reviewed by 'Joel I' on January 9, 2011
Physically a wonderful venue. Bar area warm and inviting; Steak was mediocre. Porterhouse for three was inadequate for two. Side dishes were plated like a road house diner,and to serve a tuna tartare appetizer without so much as a piece of toast let alone chips is unheard of. Further, not to have a free standing ice bucket and have to leave a table bucket is crass for the monies being spent here
Reviewed by 'Joseph R' on January 8, 2011
A pleasant atmosphere combined with great food making for a definite go to place for either a quite dinner, first date or just a break from it all.
Reviewed by 'Marilyn B' on January 5, 2011
A quintessential NY steakhouse with prime aged steaks all they should be, tho' our medium porterhouse disappointingly came cooked too rare. Sides are large, with plenty to share - best are tomato & onion salad stacked high & creamed spinach , but garlic mashed potatoes fell short. For non-carnivores there are a few fish and pasta choices, but meat reigns supreme here- the reason to go.
| 
